Regis' Rants
Total Pageviews
Thursday, December 15, 2011
Ron Paul, a "decent" guy!
When, "We need more decency among Republicans," is the operable phrase endorsing a Ron Paul candidacy, then that about sums up the current plight of the GOP. Bringing out Cheney to the talk show circuit shows the desperation in looking for but not finding a "Decent" GOP candidate. I agree that Ron Paul gives off the best image of sanity and moral decency when surrounded by the "GOP debate team" but he is no match for the current president. The GOP has simply not been willing to back a "mainstream" candidate since the rise of the religious right to the ascendency of power in the GOP and with the evolution of the Tea Party the GOP is doomed to irrelevancy until they give up their "fundamentalist" isolationism.
This country does not belong to the religious right. The fact is, that a majority of this population of voting citizens sees the government as a positive force that supports and helps everyone, not just the "monied aristocracy" and their "peopled corporations." The USA is about peace, prosperity, (for everyone), life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. This means the right to health care and basic amenities to support life as a minimum. Government is a means to help not hurt our population. My criticism of Obama is that he has not gone far enough or fought hard enough, but he is a far more substantial president then anyone in the GOP field.
Friday, November 18, 2011
Congressional Lottery (part 2)
Lottery System Excerpt: © Edip Yuksel, J.D.,* 1998
http://www.yuksel.org/e/law/lottery.htm
Every citizen who meets the qualifications enumerated in Article I, sections 2 and 3 of the Constitution could become a candidate by filling out a simple application form. This application can be automatically done during voter registration. Every registered person will have an equal chance of becoming a member of Congress. The election or selection can be conducted by mechanical devises or computers with sufficient security and supervision.
Lottery voting can work very well for choosing members for the House of Representatives since its size can absorb the few eccentric or extreme members that may result. The lottery system would not work for electing presidents or governors, since it would be too risky. An eccentric person could cause chaos. This system is not recommended for choosing senators either, since their number is relatively small, and more importantly, diversity in election methods among governmental branches creates a healthier checks and balances mechanism. The president and senators would be elected through traditional voting, judges would be appointed by elected people, and members of Congress would be directly elected through lottery.
Initially, I did not take the idea of a lottery system seriously. Remembering the ancient Greek practice of election by lottery led me to consider it as a possible alternative to conventional elections (FN55), Luis Fuentes-Rohwer, briefly evaluated this historical practice in a law review article:
Ancient Athenians adhered to a strict conception of democracy. In this sense, when they asserted that the people ruled, they meant every word of it. Their commitment to democratic rule was evident in their procedure for electing political and administrative officers. Citizens were elected to these offices randomly, without any competency or property requirement. While this proposal may seem much too radical for modern democracies, it would appear less so if our society adhered to the Athenian notion of isonomia, where all citizens are politically equal in a sense much stricter than the one espoused by American political standards (FN56).Though I do not fully subscribe to the Athenian practice of lottery elections, I believe that they might provide a healthy boost for the ailing modern democracies if lottery elections are balanced by the conventional elections. Knowing the constitutional precedent in jury selection encouraged me to reflect on the lottery election furthermore.
To my surprise, I found an article suggesting lottery election by Akhil Amar in the Yale Law Journal. In the first paragraph of the introduction, Amar expresses the theme of his article:
Under Ôlottery voting,Õ citizens would vote for representatives in local districts, much as they do today. Rather than automatically electing the candidate who receives a majority or plurality of votes, however, lottery voting chooses the winner in a lottery of the ballots cast: A single ballot is randomly drawn, and the candidate chosen on that ballot wins the election. If A receives sixty percent of the overall vote and B gets forty percent, A does not automatically win; rather, AÕs ex ante chances of winning are sixty percent and BÕs are forty percent (FN57).AmarÕs concern is not the influence of money or interest groups, but proportional representation of minorities. His lottery system, therefore, does not cure the corruption caused by lobbies. Instead of being primarily used for the election of representatives, the money would be used to elect candidates.
When I started discussing the issue with my classmates and professors, their initial reaction to the idea was generally the typical negative reaction to the unfamiliar. Experiencing the same reaction, Amar, a decade later wrote another article in defense of his proposal. He wrote:
Now I am sure that some people will think that this lottery voting system is at first blush preposterous, absurd, weird, Yale-ish or whatever; but hear me out. Perhaps this initial reaction is itself a reflection of how little most people understand social choice theory (and sometimes simple math). What else generates the initial reaction of resistance? Let me talk about some of the possibilities, and in the course of doing so I'll lay out some of the things that I think we can learn by taking lottery voting seriously--at least as a thought experiment (FN58).After discussing the issue with a score of people and reading relevant materials, certain details and arguments for a lottery election evolved. LetÕs first consider some of the advantages of a lottery system over the current political system and then go over some details.
1. The current political system favors the wealthy and well-organized at the cost of the poor and those who lack the resources for lobbying activities. The lottery system, on the other hand, would be blind to such factors.
2. The current political system is costly for society. Time and energy spent on fund-raising activities distract incumbent legislators from focusing on the job they were elected to do. The wasteful and negative spending of contributions on pollsters, spinners, twisters, and dirty ads create mind pollution and misinformation. A lottery system, however, would neither require nor encourage such corruption.
3. The current political system is elitist. It does not reflect the diverse demographic profile of America. Women, ethnic and minority groups have always been underrepresented. The social background of the members of Congress is evidence of this elitism. "No myth dies harder in American politics than the log cabin, rags-to-riches notion that anyone can be elected president or a member of Congress. Although there are exceptions to the normal patterns, age, fatherÕs occupation, family connections, and education are significant determinants of who is elected to Congress." (FN59). For instance, eight presidents, three vice presidents, thirty senators, twelve governors, fifty-six House members, and nine cabinet officers belong to just sixteen "dynasty" families (FN60). "Blue-collar workers, the service sector, and farmers are underrepresented. About three-fourths of the members of Congress come from banking, business or law activities." (FN61). A lottery system would be blind to these biases in political representation.
4. The current political system has created political apathy and disillusionment. The percentage of voters is alarmingly low. People are losing faith in the political process and in government so much so that opportunistic politicians are trying a foolish tactic of distancing themselves from government and politics. A congress elected by lottery voting would statistically reflect a cross-section of the population and would bring back faith in and respect for democracy.
5. By limiting the lottery election to the House we can still experience the "exciting" adventure of the electoral process for members of the Senate and the president. Having some legislators who do not owe their allegiance to any interest-group will create a healthier checks and balances mechanism among the branches of American government.
6. Professional politicians usually produce laws with complicated language and jargons. Lottery elections will help to simplify the language of legislation (FN62).
Some details
Keeping a crystal clear rule, such as "one person, one chance" has great advantages for its simplicity and popular appeal. But, we may need to address some possible problems. The following specific details are just some thoughts regarding certain issues. Therefore, they should not be evaluated based on their specific contents; but on the relevancy and validity of the underlying concerns.
There is a reasonable argument for a certain degree of manipulation of chances. In view of the strong correlation between education and amount of acquired knowledge, citizensÕ chances could be increased proportional to their education. (Illiteracy could be considered a reason for disqualification as well as having a record of mental instability.) For instance, a high school degree may increase their chance by 2, a university degree by 4, a doctorate by 8. Valuing education level as the only favoring factor can be criticized as an elitist manipulation; but it still has an advantage over the current system, since it would still be virtually blind to gender, religion, family connection, wealth, occupation, etc. Yet, even after the education-biased adjustment, the Congress elected by lottery probably would have less educated members than the current Congress. Approximately 90 percent of congressmen hold a college degree, compared to 17 percent of the American population (FN63). The people who have practically no chance of getting elected in the current system thus would have at least a chance to be elected in an educationally manipulated lottery system.
To attract those elected to accept the job, salaries should be equal to the annual income of the median American family or to the salary of previous occupation, whichever is greater. Those who are employed by the government will be guaranteed a return to their previous positions after the end of their terms.
To encourage participation in the legislative process and discourage vacations and indolence, some incentives could be designed. For instance, those who attend the House meetings, say more than 200 days a year will be on a special list of the next lottery elections. Out of this list, up to 50 names could be drawn for the second and last term. The number of re-elected representatives should not exceed 10 percent of the total. This incentive may also create a healthy dose of continuity in a House whose members statistically have zero chance of re-election.
Finally, this model should first be tested in the government of small cities. If the results are promising then its scope can be widened to include the House of Representatives.
Lottery Elections For Redistricting Committee In The Pima County
While writing this paper I received surprise news from my professor. Pima County, Arizona had decided to elect the Redistricting Committee members through lottery election. Here is the relevant part of the draft:
Section 6.01 Board Districts; Adjustment of Districts (To be Considered on April 7, 1997)
A. There shall be five supervisorial districts.
B. The process of drawing supervisorial districts shall be independent of the Board.
C. There shall be a Redistricting Committee of eleven (11) members, selected at random from a list of all registered voters in County. Using commonly accepted methods of random selection, the County Attorney shall administer the selection process. At a public drawing, the County Attorney or his or her representative shall develop a list of potential Committee members. The County Attorney shall contact each individual on the list, describe to him or her the tasks that would be involved with serving on the Redistricting Committee, and determine whether each individual would be willing to serve as a member of Redistricting Committee. From among those expressing willingness to serve, there shall be a second random selection process, which shall produce an initial list of eleven (11) committee members and fifteen (15) alternatives. From this initial list, each member of the Board may delete, in his or her unfettered discretion, on prospective Committee member from the list. After Board members have exercised this power, any vacancies on the Committee shall be filled from the list of remaining alternates. As the Committee undertakes its responsibilities, any vacancies that occur shall be filled from the remaining list of alternates (FN64).
Instead of elimination, I would propose selection. Each Board member should elect the ones that they think the fittest for the committee. This way, hopefully, the strongest candidates will be elected to the committee. The selection will also put a certain degree of responsibility on those who did the selection.
Arguments
There are legitimate concerns, questions and criticism regarding the conse-quence of lottery elections. Of those, I will respond to the five important ones. Below, the questions or concerns are written in bold characters, each followed by my response.
I.
Selection by lottery would be random, so the quality of their decisions would indeed be far more reflective of the population at large than the quality of the decisions of the current body. However, once they have relocated to Washington and begun deliberating, they will gradually deviate more and more from the population due to the (now) unique conditions under which they make their decisions (an office in Washington, lots of power, etc.). They would thus be more representative of the general population than the current body, but we could never attain perfect representativeness (in a statistical sense) by selecting people and sending them to Washington (FN66).
True, power corrupts; however, there are good reasons to be optimistic. First, there are available measures. All gifts or contributions can be prohibited for the entire term. Like all federal employees, the House members will be subject to the employment law. There won't be a First Amendment problem since there won't no political campaign for their election. Furthermore, the lack of lengthy campaign activities or the probable lack of previous political activities will provide some extra time for those who are susceptible to corruption. The elected members for the House are corrupted by the power of money long before they are elected. They need money if they want to serve in the office. Even those who abhor the corruption and influence of money are obliged to bow down to this corrupt process. It is a Catch 22.
What is to prevent the elected individuals from maximizing their self-interest? Nothing. But, we should pray that they would look after their self-interest, in terms of voting for a particular legislation. Why? Because their self-interest is statistically analogous to the very self-interest of the general population. The very nature of the sample body will make such worries trivial.
The lottery-elected representatives with their diverse backgrounds will have less propensity for misrepresentation. For instance, a small businessman who was elected for four years to represent his district will be concerned about both the interest of his district and small businesses and after four years of service he will probably turn to his previous job. He has friends and perhaps relatives are in that sector. If he looks after his interest he will be protecting the class or the category of the population he is coming from. Similarly, the teachers, the factory employees, the secretaries, the jobless, the doctors, the housewives, the blacks, the blues, the greens will be expected to promote their self-interest. The negotiation among diverse interests will create compromises for the interest of the entire population.
II.
435 people constitute a rather small sample size. Where public opinion is evenly divided over some issue, the statistical uncertainty is plus-or-minus 4.7% if you can tolerate one out of twenty decisions' not being representative of the population (although close). That's the 95% confidence interval criterion, which is the one most commonly used. The implications for the decision-making body are that you need a margin of at least 4.7% to constitute a plurality in any decision. Thus, for example, if the vote is 235 to 200 to ban handguns, you have an 8% spread and therefore the ban should pass. However, if the spread is 20 or less, e.g., only 227 to 208, then there is no way to tell whose side actually represents the dominant position in the population, so no action could be taken that ostensibly represents the "popular" view (FN67).
This problem can be reduced by increasing the number of seats, but this will be a trade off from efficiency. It will take much longer to pass legislation in a House with a larger population. This problem is inherent in all democratic bodies. There will be always some imprecision in both elections and representation as well. We do not have a solution for this problem in a representative democracy. As for referendums, it is practically impossible to have referendums for every piece of legislation. Besides the efficiency and participation, the quality of referendums will be another concern. Time constraints of citizens and misinformation eliminates frequent referendums from being an alternative to representative system.
Here, I would like to shed an optimistic light on the problem of statistical uncertainty in representing the "popular" view. Close margins might work against "popular" view, but still they will not be very "unpopular," since they will represent, according to the hypothetical, approximately 45% of the population. Furthermore, the random nature of lottery election will not let this anomaly continue forever. Within several elections the close margins might work in favor of the "popular" view. True, most of us have primary concerns, but we know that our interest in the legislation usually involves more than a single-issue. Since we have little reason to believe that lottery-elected members will limit their diverse perspectives within the political lines of the two major parties, future legislation might reduce the impact of past legislation accepted with close margins. The close margin that worked against the slightly "popular" view of hand-gun owners, in another vote, might please most of them with a slightly "unpopular" legislation, say, permitting the hunting of hyenas with arrows.
III.
An election through lottery will give too much negotiation power to a few eccentrics in cases where the margin of opposing views is too close (FN68).
This appears to be a legitimate concern, however, the problem is not unique to lottery election. Any population, be it elected by lottery or by popular vote, will always have some eccentric individuals, since eccentricity is a relative concept. Putting aside the problem in defining the "eccentric" in an absolute sense, I think it is not something to worry about. The divided "non-eccentrics" will obviously will not become eccentric themselves, since it is not a contagious disease. Therefore, they may prefer compromising with the other "non-eccentric" parties instead of going along with the "deviant" or "bizarre" wishes of the few "eccentric" ones. Why worry about the free-market of ideas?
If this is a really serious concern, I will suggest a process of selection by the Senate. Each senator can be granted a right of picking half of the lottery-elected candidates coming from his/her district. For instance, the Arizona senators McCain and Kyl each will pick three new House members out of total 12 candidates who were elected by the lottery conducted in Arizona. This process might also relieve another legitimate concern regarding the quality of lottery-elect body. As I argued above, the elimination process tends to reduce the quality of remaining population. Each senator will be tempted to eliminate the most potent candidates that he/she thinks has opposing political convictions. But, if they are required to select among the elected ones, then, they will most likely pick the ones that they consider the most potent ones.
IV.
A lottery system could minimize influence. It would produce a cross section of the population and all gifts or contributions could be banned. There would be no need for political campaigning. Instead of citizen soldiers, we could have citizen politicians with rotation in office. However, elections might be viewed as performing a valuable function. There may be a need for more than a cross section of the population. Elections may furnish that quality. This view may necessitate the acceptance of a system which permits influence in order to be able to get the benefit of those other qualities. More important, perhaps elections are the source of a class of the population which makes political issues its professional specialty. Without elections there would be no class of professional politicians and, therefore, no group whose function it was to study the public's desires and interests. Political parties came into being to contest elections. Without them, it is not clear what the information and normative world facing representatives elected through a lottery system would be like. Moreover, the process of discussion would be enervated without parties and professionals. Elections educate and representatives' views form part of the definition of their constituents' interests. In other words, free speech may depend on the people it is designed to oversee. Without free speech, it may be institutionally difficult to conduct the discussion necessary to enlightened self-government. As a consequence, competition is fundamental (FN6).
That's one of the reasons why I propose the lottery election for only House members. Employing lottery elections for a part of the government, therefore, does not exterminate political parties and their professional politicians. They will remain as a dynamic factor in the elections of Senate members and Presidency and they will have the power to influence the results of lottery elections to a certain degree. However, a money-dependent corrupt system generating corrupt politicians is the side-affect of the modern democracies. Trying to reduce this side-effect is essential for the survival of the democratic system.
V.
Conducting the lottery through computer might create suspicion and paranoid conspiracy ideas in the society (FN70).
Computers are closed boxes (like close societies) and God knows what goes on inside their chips and circuits. Software and hardware programs, for instance, can be secretly designed to manipulate the results. Even the micro-chip manufacturers might manufacture chips that will pick the social security numbers from their hidden memories. Therefore, the lottery election should be done in each state via mechanical (not electronic) lottery devices. Many states have lotto or powerball drawings. (Ironically, I consider this sort of lottery an unjust distribution of wealth and exploitation of dreams). Apple-size balls, each stamped with visible large numbers are in a transparent sphere and they are one by one pulled out by a machine. The simple mechanics and visibility of this drawing combined with live broadcasting via TV leaves no room for reasonable suspicion. When we add the fact that the lottery election will be monitored by rival politicians, the process of lottery-election becomes a reliable random drawing.
The lottery election can be done in a previously announced hour, so that the citizens of that state can experience a live political (?) spectacle on their TV (FN71). Each drawing will declare a 9-digit number presumably indicating a social security number of a candidate. This number could be immediately put into the nearby computer. If the computer matches it with the social security number of a registered eligible citizen, then the name of the primary candidate would be announced.
Simply-designed application forms for candidacy should contain several multiple choice questions to assess the eligibility or chance factor for each applicant. Those forms will be automatically scanned to computers and the data will be used both during the lottery election and afterwards. Here, the reliability of computers is not an issue, since it is about retrieving stored data which can be checked anytime later. For instance, in Arizona, twelve of the eligible primary candidates will be declared to be the final candidates. Six of them, later, will be approved by Arizona senators and they will become the new members of the House.
Conclusion
We might still consider American government "by the people," but we are becoming less sure whether it is "for the people" and "of the people." (FN72). It is incumbent on us to protect our republic and democracy from the hegemony of interest-groups and money. Otherwise, the name of our political system should be officially changed from democracy to lobbyocracy or cashocracy, if we want to avoid hypocrisy.
The lottery system is just one of the alternative solutions. If it works for selecting 12 members of a jury, then, it could work for selecting 435 or more members of Congress. We are trusting the decision of 12 randomly chosen citizens on life and death issues, why not trust 435 randomly chosen citizens to participate in running the government?
FOOTNOTES
* Author, human rights activist. J.D., University of Arizona College of Law (1998). The author is thankful to Toni M. Massaro, professor at the University of Arizona College of Law, for her encouraging and helpful comments on this article. My ultimate thanks go to God for enabling me to immigrate to America, the land of freedom. Author can be reached via
1 For the story of this human propensity in the domain of property use, see: Carol Rose, Property as Storytelling, 2 Yale J.L. & Humanities 37, 50 (1990).
2 The 1990 Webster's College Dictionary defines democracy as: government by the people; a form of government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised directly by them or by their elected agents under a free electoral system.
3 Unfortunately this is true. "In nine out of ten Congressional races, the candidate with the most money winsÑeven in the 'revolutionary' elections of 1994." (Center for Responsive Politics, http://www.crp.org/net/reform.html).
4 George Soros, The Capitalist Threat, Atlantic Monthly, February 1997, pp. 45-58.
5 Federal Reserve Board, in March 1992 released a paper showing a dramatic increase in the concentration of wealth between 1983 and 1992, with the share of the top 1 percent of families rising from 31 to 37 percent. For an excellent article evaluating the Census data on the growing gap between the rich and poor, see: Paul R. Krugman, The Rich, the Right and the Facts; Deconstructing the Income Distribution Debate, The American Prospect, No. 11, (Fall 1992): 19-31. For another excellent article on the growing income gap, see: Robert H. Frank, Talent and the Winner-Take-All Society, The American Prospect, No. 17 (Spring 1994): 97-107.
6 The U.S. News & World Report published a spectacular report titled Hang on to your wallet in its April 14, 1997 issue, pp. 26-31. I recommend this report for those who wonder the dimension of plunder conducted by corporations and their accomplice legislators. Here are some excerpts from the report: "TV station owners got $30 billion worth of free licenses without being required to give free TV time to political candidates. The power of political money sabotaged the best chance to reduce the power of political money. . . Cable TV lobbyists promised that competition would mean low cable rates. Competition hasn't increased. Cable rates have. . . Lawmakers once banned dubious 'dread disease' insurance policies. But industry money helped change their minds."
7 Id. at 27.
8 Id. at 27.
9 Id. at 30.
10 Id. at 31.
11 Susan Page, White House has big-donor jitters, USA Today, April, 8, 1997, 6A.
12 In recent presidential elections, American voter turnout has been little more than 50%:
1960 Kennedy-Nixon 63.1%
1964 Johnson-Goldwater 61.8%
1968 Humphrey-Nixon 60.7%
1972 McGovern-Nixon 55.4%
1976 Carter-Ford 54.4%
1980 Carter-Reagan 52.6%
1984 Mondale-Reagan 53.1%
1988 Bush-Dukakis 50.1%
1992 Bush-Clinton 55.2%
Congressional Quarterly's Guide to U.S. Elections, Congressional Quarterly Inc., Washington, D.C., 1994, pp. 420-422. & Congressional Quarterly's Guide to U.S. Elections, Congressional Quarterly Inc., Washington, D.C., 1982, p. 615.
13 Voters Key Issues Unaddressed by Legislators, Survey Indicates, The Arizona Daily Star, June 16, 1996, 1A.
14 Id.
15 Kenneth T. Walsh, No Shame and Lots of Gain, U.S. News & World Report, March 3, 1997, p. 32.
16 For the alphabetical list of 17,500 lobbyists who advocate on behalf of various companies, labor unions, associations, government entities and special interest groups see: Washington Representatives, J. Valerie Steele, eds. et al., Columbia Books Inc., Washington DC., (1996). (http:www.d-net.com/columbia). Lobbying is considered a Constitutional right under the last clause of the 1st Amendment: "the right of the people . . . to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." Wondering whether I am not aware of the full meaning of the word "petition" I consulted my Random House Webster's Dictionary (1991). I could not find "financial contribution" in the definition of petition! Extending the Constitutional right to the main practice of today's special-interest lobbying that has beleaguered Washington and State capitals requires a religious dedication to the philosophy of Adam Smith.
17 Ronald Dworkin articulated this fact from the horse's mouth: "But money is the biggest threat to the democratic process. The time politicians must spend raising money in endless party functions and in more personal waysÑnot only during an election campaign but while in office, preparing for the next electionÑhas become an increasingly large drain on their attention. Senator Tom Harkin of Iowa complained in 1988. 'As soon as a Senator is elected here, that Senator better start raising money for the next election 6 years down the pike. Everyone here does it, and to deny that is to deny the obvious and to deny what is also in the record.'" Ronald Dworkin, The Curse of American Politics, The New York Review of Books, October 17, 1996, p. 19.
18 Political Action Committees are political entities that engage in election-related activities. PACs are affiliated with corporations, labor unions, political organizations, etc. The number of PACs has risen dramatically in last 20 years, from 608 PACs in 1976 to more than 4,000 PACs in 1996. For the list of PACs and their political contribution and financial tables, see: The PAC Directory, The Federal Committees, edited by David U. Geevy, Chadwick R. Gore, and Marvin I. Weinberger, Pac Research Ltd. Ballinger Publishing Co., Cambridge, MA (1991).
19 See: David Grann, infra note 42, at 23.
20 Buckley v Valeo, 481 U.S. 1, 20 (1976)
21 See: The PAC Directory, supra note 18.
22 435 U.S. 765 (1978)
23 First National Bank v Bellotti, 435 U.S. 765, 791 (1978)
24 Id., at 807
25 Id., at 807
26 Bruce B. Auster with David Bowermaster, Playing The Money Game, U.S. News & World Report, May 20, 1996, p. 25.
27 Soft money' apparently too hard for U.S. lawmakers to relinquish, The Arizona Daily Star, April 6, 1997, (quoting from The New York Times).
28 Lexington, Al Gore falls to earth, The Economist, March 8, 1997.
29 Michael Kinsley, The Conspiracy of Trivia, Time, March 17, 1997, p. 25.
30 According to the Newsweek magazine, The Lincoln Bedroom was not the only thing for sale. A menu of the perks were out for sale in three packages: For $12,500, dinner and your picture taken with the president at a Washington hotel. For $50,000, coffee with Clinton and top administration at the White House. For $250,000, a full day at the White House. (Strange Bedfellows, Newsweek, March 10, 1997, p. 28). The commercial use of White House, is by no means a Clinton innovation. See: William M. Welch, GOP also used White House to attract big-money donors, USA Today, February, 26, 1997.
31 Alison Mitchel, President Regrets Top U.S. Regulator Met With Bankers, The New York Times, January 29, 1997, front page. The USA Today in its April 17, 1997 issue published the list of top 150 contributors to political parties in 1995 and 1996. (p. 6A). The donations were ranging between $138,000 and $661,000.
32 Nancy Gibbs, The Wake-Up Call, Time, February 3, 1997,
33 Robert B. Reich, Locked In The Cabinet, The New Yorker, April 21, 1977, p. 49.
34 Marilyn Vos Savant, Ask Marilyn, Parade Magazine, April 6, 1997, p. 9.
35 Congressional Quarterly's Guide to U.S. Elections, Congressional Quarterly Inc., Washington, D.C., 1982, pp. 584-585.
36 David Grann and Erica Niedowski, The Dirty Hill, The New Republic, April 7, 1997, p. 21.
37 Id.
38 William M. Welch, GOP also used White House to attract big-money donors, USA Today, February 26, 1997.
39 Colorado Republican Federal Campaign Committee v. Federal Election Commission, 116 S.Ct. 2309, 2332, (1996). (Stevens, Ginsberg, JJ., dissenting).
40 Colorado Republican, Supra note 39, at 2332.
41 Kenneth T. Walsh, No shame and lots to gain, U.S. News & World Report, March 3, 1997, p.32.
42 David Grann and Erika Niedowski, The Dirty Hill, The New Republic, April 7, 1997, p. 23. The authors give some examples of bizarre fund-raising methods: "Former Republican Representative Enid Waldholtz of Utah, whose ex-husband was investigated for illegally pouring money into her campaign, became so anxious to fill her coffers that she exploited the birth of her first child. Days after she had given birth to Elizabeth in 1995, Waldholtz threw a party to introduce her little girlÑnot to family or close friends, but to $500-a-head contributors. GOP Congressman Bud Shuster of Pennsylvania has turned his birthday party into a $1,000-a-plate affair. And a former Democratic Congresswoman Barbara Rose Collins, in pursuit of money, even held a fund-raiser at a strip club in Detroit."
43 Harold W. Stanley & Richard G. Niemi, Vital Statistics On American Politics, Congressional Quarterly Inc., Washington, 1988, p.157.
44 Campaign contributions reflect Congress' voting, study shows, The Arizona Daily Star, January 23, 1997.
45 Id.
46 "It is sometimes said all that's being bought and sold is merely "access," not government policy itself. But access is worthless if it doesn't affect policy, and experience has thought those who contribute that access works. And to state the obvious: it is unfair and undemocratic for those who buy access to have bigger voice in government than those who don't." Michael Kinsley, The Conspiracy of Trivia, Time, March 17, 1997, p. 25.
47 Valerie Steele, supra note 16.
48 Nancy Gibbs, The Wake-Up Call, Time, February 3, 1997.
49 Time magazine briefly listed the five current reform bills and called McCain-Feingold bill a "dying" bill. Here are the "Five ways to fix the campaign Finance System:
1. The (dying) McCain-Feingold Bill: It would ban soft money, limit contributions from PACs and set voluntary spending limits for congressional candidates. Will it pass? Don't bet on it.
2. Amend The U.S. Constitution: Spending caps could swallow the money chase. But the Supreme Court says limits violate free-speech guarantees. Carve out an exception to the First Amendment?
3. More Taxpayer-Supported Races: Presidential candidates who agree to spending caps get public financing for their campaigns. One Senate bill would extend that system to congressional races.
4. Give Candidates Cheaper Airtime: To cut campaign costs and the attendant fund-raising frenzy, have FEC distribute vouchers for TV and radio time that stations would be required to donate.
5. Let More Sunshine In: Lift all limits on money, but require candidates and parties to disclose data on contributors more fully, frequently and widely. On idea: post it all on the Internet."
Nancy Gibbs and Michael Duffy, Legal Tender, Time, March 17, 1997.
50 Walter Shapiro, The universal refrain for campaign reform: Let it be, USA Today, Aril 25, 1997, p. 12A. Gloria Borger, Also see, Cynical, even for Congress, U.S. News & World Report, March 3, 1997. p. 42: "Few senators really want full scale hearings that could bring down the campaign system."
51 Richard L. Hasen, Clipping Coupons for Democracy: An Egalitarian/Public Choice Defense of Campaign Finance Vouchers, 84 California Law Review 1, 6-7, (1996).
52 http://epn.org/prospect/
53 Ronald Dworkin, supra note 17, at 23.
54 Ted Wachtel, The Electronic Congress: A Blue Print for Participatory Democracy, 56 (1992).
55 Wai Chee Dimock, Residues of Justice, University of California Press, Berkely, 1996. The author dedicates a chapter to Lottery (p. 96) and refers to Barbara Goodwin's book Justice by Lottery (1992).
56 Luis Fuentes-Rohwer, The Emptiness Of Majority Rule, 1 Mich. J. Race & L. 195, 218-219 (1996).
57 Akhil Reed Amar, Choosing Representatives By Lottery Voting, 93 Yale L.J. 1283, (1984).
58 Akhil Reed Amar, Lottery Voting: A Thought Experiment, 1995 U. Chi. Legal F. 193, 195 (1995).
59 The Encyclopedia of the United States Congress, Simon & Schuster, 1995, p. 1337.
60 Id. at 1347.
61 Id. at 1347.
62 Professor Toni M. Massaro counted this among the good reasons for having jury trials: "This humanizing function serves the community by helping the law to operate in a way that is comprehensible to the people the law must serve. If legal theories are too complex for jurors, who represent the nonlegal community, then the theories must be simplified. Otherwise, the citizen who must abide by the law will not understand what it requires and therefore may not conform to its dictates." Toni M. Massaro, Peremptories Or Peers?-Rethinking Sixth Amendment Doctrine, Images, and Procedures, 64 N.C. L. Rev. 501, 514 (1986). Massaro's article gives a brief historical account of trial by jury and proposes a "modest" change in the jury selection procedure and calls for abolishing the government's peremptory challenges.
63 The Encyclopedia of the United State Congress, Simon & Schuster, 1995, pp. 1371-1384. Also see: Congress A to Z, Congressional Quarterly Inc., Washington D.C., 1968, pp. 279-281.
64 Draft- Pima County Charter; April 7, 1998; Pp. 10. The Pima County Charter's draft has other provisions such as the qualifications of members of the Redistricting Committee and their terms, etc.
65 Professor Amar reminded the readers the jury system as an example of his version of lottery election. Nevertheless, he preferred a jury selection free of interference: "But lotteries, you say. How can lotteries be anything but an abdication to irrationality and arbitrariness? Well, let's think about a place where we do use lotteries to vindicate ideas of political equality and democratic deliberation: the jury. Here, we might put all the voters in a drum and pick twelve people out and they are your jury. This would be a different way of picking jurors than our current system, but the Supreme Court is, I hope, moving in that direction. It has focused much more in the last decade on the right of jurors to be represented and to participate rather than on the right of defendants to decide who will be on their jury. So the Court has been restricting peremptory challenges and other exclusionary measures. The Justices are moving towards an earlier vision that saw some interesting connections between the people's representation in the lower house of the judicial branch through the jury and the people's representation in the legislature itself." Amar, Supra note 58, at 201.
66 This criticism was e-mailed to me by Richard Steven Voss, a Ph.D. candidate in Business Management.
67 Id.
68 This concern was raised orally by Robert Glennon, a law professor at University of Arizona.
69 Stephen E. Gottlieb, The Dilemma Of Election Campaign Finance Reform, 18 Hofstra L. Rev. 213, 268-269 (Fall, 1989).
70 This concern expressing distrust to electronic machines is from me. Though my computers have been my best confidants for more than a decade, I know that they are vulnerable to manipulations.
71 This spectacle is primarily intended for those who crave the excitement of campaigns and the ritual of poking holes in cards in isolated dull compartments! Indeed, a whole night can be dedicated on lottery election on network TV channels, hosted by Letterman and Rush Limbaugh!
72 This popular expression is from Lincoln's famous Gettysburg address in 1863. Lincoln defined democracy as: "a government of the people, by the people, for the people. . . our concept of democracy includes universal suffrage-one person, one vote-with freely conducted secret elections at stipulated intervals depending upon the location and the office. All governmental matters are subject to the Constitution of the United States, and to the several separate constitutions of the individual states."
Thursday, October 27, 2011
Congressional Lottery
It is time to overhaul the congressional/political system in the US or a social revolution will take hold and bring down the banks and corporations. Congress membership should be established with a national lottery with allotments by state according to population and a 3 year term limit. 1/3 new membership each year. The congress should be made up of "We the People," and not a bunch of millionaire career politicians.
Saturday, September 10, 2011
"What goes around comes around." Israel has help create a country for itself which will feel more and more like a quarantine. The previous administrations in the US have supported Israel in it's unyielding discrimination toward Arabs generally and Palestinians specifically. Now Israel has become an island in an ever more inhospitable sea. It is not too late. Get on the right side of history and help your Palestinian brothers and sisters set up an independent state and kick the war mongers out of your government.
Saturday, August 27, 2011
Regis' Rants: Generation "Fixx It"
The Windy Wet Weather back East
If I were 18 and just starting my college education, I would prefer to believe that all is well and my future is bright in spite of the wicked acts that past generations unleashed on "our" planet. The truth is probably somewhere in between. Things are bad but maybe not so bad that my daughter's generation can't turn it around once they are able to admit that there are serious problems.